This requires some sensitivity. If kids are going to critique each other’s work, they need to be honest but constructive. The notes are for discussion, like “two stars and a wish.” They are not for the kids to trash each other’s work. This rubric is a good way for kids to get involved in the writers workshop model of creative writing. The grading section at the bottom is optional, but kids often think in terms of grading, so it’s good for feedback.